A friend of mine (actually a former instructor) recently sent me a thought-provoking email. Here's a clip:

I can tell that you're someone who enjoys argument, so let me for the sake of debate make the following claim: the debate over evolution and creationism is much ado about (almost) nothing. Setting aside my belief that creationists greatly exaggerate the dangers posed by evolution, I just don't think the issue is all that urgent. Especially when compared to the threats posed by global fundamentalisms, or overconsumption, or nuclear proliferation.

This is an important question, especially at UCI where many students (including myself at times) are on the apathetic side of the spectrum. What is the practical relevance of discussing issues like evolution, creation, and intelligent design? Or in even more practical terms, how can we get people to attend our major event of the quarter?

Let me offer a few possible answers:

• The issue of origins is fundamentally interesting.
• This issue of origins deals with a fundamental search for ultimate truth. Our conceptions on this issue determine our worldview and have important theological and societal implications.
• People are generally interested in hearing all possible sides of an issue. Courses at school can do a great job of teaching aspects of Darwinian evolution. Events like our major event of the quarter can provide rational alternatives on this issue.
• One's perspective on this issue can influence one's political outlook (e.g. is there a correlation between creationists and pro-lifers? or between darwinians and stem-cell supporters?).
• Having a friendly discussion on these issues has the potential to augment a student's desire to "do the homework" and become better informed on scientific issues.
• Darwinian evolution is assumed in almost every field of study at the university. A paradigm shift towards design could perhaps restructure much of what we know now and lead to even bigger discoveries.